"Stage-managed" eh? As to imply that this is just some sort of staged political photo-op, no doubt. It wasn't, but regardless it is not Jonathan Katz' job as an AP reporter to make that assumption in the first place.
He then goes on to say (emphasis mine):
It should be noted that Greta Van Susteren was asked by Franklin Graham (this is not the first time Greta has accompanied Graham on an overseas trip) to come to Haiti, it wasn't Governor Palin who set that up.
Rebecca Mansour weighed in on Twitter to say:
Jonathan Katz of the Associated Press is a liar. He knows very well that Samaritan's Purse was in charge of press in Haiti, not Gov. Palin.Also
I told him myself repeatedly. He also knows very well that for security reasons, Samaritan's Purse did not want to release their itinerary.Katz and others in the media seem to be saying two different things in their articles about Governor Palin's trip to Haiti. They imply it was a photo-op on one hand, then complain about a lack of access on the other. So which is it? I gather this is just more, 'throw the kitchen sink' at Governor Palin to see what sticks.
Jonathan Katz then writes:
Why is JonathanKatz reporting on Governor's Palin's wardrobe? The last time I checked, Katz wasn't a fashion reporter. Who cares what Governor Palin wore on a humanitarian mission? Some might say that it was sexist of Katz to include that in his article. I'll leave that up to readers to decide for themselves.
By the way, as Ian noted earlier, Governor Palin and Franklin Graham held a press conference on Sunday in Haiti from the Samaritan's Purse camp. So, no this trip was not closed to the media. You can see a photo from that presser here.
Update: I was just reminded that the Hong Kong speech was not closed to the media. Katz was wrong about that as well. The Wall Street Journal covered the Hong Kong event here.